FAQ
EB5 Visa
There are several basic requirements for an EB5 visa.
Invest the minimum amount in a qualified US business (“New Commercial Enterprise” or NCE) or approved regional center
Create 10 permanent jobs (direct or indirect) for American workers with the NCE
There are three steps to the EB5 process:
- I-526 Petition: Once an investor has made the required investment, they would file the I-526 petition. This petition includes project documents and documents related to the investor’s source of funds.
- Conditional Resident Application: USCIS is currently allowing for concurrent filing of a green card application. This means that most applicants, except for those born in India, China, and Vietnam, are eligible to apply for their green card along with the I-526 petition if they are present in the U.S. and meet specific requirements. Otherwise, upon approval of the I-526 petition, if their priority date is current, the investor and family can apply for their conditional green card. The conditional green card, once approved, is valid for 2 years. Within the 90 days before the expiration of the green card, the investor and family members apply to remove the conditions on their green card by filing form I-829.
- Form I-829: USCIS will review the and confirm that the investor’s funds stayed at risk throughout conditional resident status and the project created the necessary jobs. Once the I-829 is approved, the investor and family are lawful permanent residents of the U.S.
Congress has allocated approximately 10,000 visa numbers for EB5 investors and family members. Under the 2022 EB5 Integrity and Reform Act (“RIA”), 32% of the annual EB5 immigrant visa quota is set aside for specific types of TEA projects. Here is the breakdown of what those set-asides are reserved for:
- 20% are for those investing in a rural area of the United States;
- 10% are for those investing in a high unemployment area (designated by USCIS);
- 2% are for those investing in qualified infrastructure projects administered by a government entity.
Absolutely not. An individual may continue to wait for approval of the I-140 before filing the I-485, and in many cases we advise that it is prudent to wait. However, in cases where the person’s ability to extend their H-1B nonimmigrant status past their six-year maximum under AC-21 can be limited by the timing of the filing of the I-485 when their priority date is current, we advise to please check with the attorney since, in those cases, it would be prudent to file the I-485 concurrently with the I-140.
Unfortunately, no. You cannot use your EB2 or EB3 Priority Date for your EB5 petition. Your EB5 priority date is the date USCIS received your I-526 Petition.
Yes. Unfortunately, the country against which you are “charged” for your visa number is your country of birth. Because you were born in a backlogged country, your visa and that of your family will be charged against the visa numbers for that country.
EB1 Visa
A very significant part of our practice is focused on representing individuals seeking to qualify for permanent residence (“green card”) through the Extraordinary, Exceptional, Outstanding, or National Interest categories. Our success rate is such that over 25 universities, hospitals and research institutions, as well as other immigration attorneys, refer individuals to our firm to prepare these petitions.
The firm’s EB1 practice team works closely with you to prepare a petition that clearly reflects how your achievements meet the EB1 and/or EB2 regulatory standards. In addition to working with you, we assist in framing your achievements in terms a lay person can understand. Our success with these petitions is based in large part on the time we spend understanding the nature and significance of your achievements and translating very technical concepts into terms that the immigration adjudicators can understand and appreciate. These detailed explanations, coupled with corroborating documentation, provide a picture of your accomplishments that facilitates the immigration examiner’s understanding of just how extraordinary you are.
Concurrent filing is available to individuals eligible to adjust to permanent resident status at the time an I-140 is filed on their behalf to classify them in the EB1 category (alien of extraordinary ability, outstanding researcher, multi-national manager); the EB2 category (advanced degree professional, national interest waiver; alien with exceptional ability); or the EB3 category (professional or skilled worker). An immigrant visa number must be immediately available, meaning that the priority date must be current.
Persons who have engaged in unauthorized employment or otherwise violated their nonimmigrant status may not be eligible. Similarly, persons who are subject to the two-year home residence requirement are not eligible unless this requirement has been waived or the obligation has been fulfilled.
We will provide you a fixed legal fee during the consultation once we evaluate your case. The legal fee is broken down based on the stages of preparation and filing, and a breakdown will also be provided during your consultation. Please ask any questions you may have about the quoted legal fee and what it includes. The legal fee includes all of the legal services specified above, as well as our preparation of a detailed transmittal letter to USCIS explaining how and why you qualify for EB1 or NIW, advice regarding premium processing and concurrent filing, preparation of all government forms, preparation of applications for permanent residence, preparation of applications for employment authorization, preparation of applications for travel documents, prompt response to all telephonic and email inquiries, and follow up with USCIS if there are processing delays. In addition, we do not bill separately for miscellaneous costs and expenses, including photocopies and FedEx. Rather, we add 6% to each legal fee payment to cover the expenses. We accept Visa, MasterCard and Discover.
This determination is made on a case-by-case basis. In some instances, we recommend filing both an EB1 and EB2 NIW if the NIW is stronger, but you are subject to a backlog in the EB2 category. If filed at the same time, we charge a reduced rate for the second petition. We will work with you to determine the best option for you.
EB3 Visa
Yes. Most, if not all EB3 cases allow you to expedite the I-140 processing time using an optional service known as premium processing. By filling out the I-907 form and paying the $2,500 fee, you can have your petition’s time shortened to just 15 calendar days.
However, just because your petition is approved in 15 days, doesn’t mean that you can get your green card then. You will still need to wait for your priority date to be current. Speak with your immigration attorney to learn if premium processing is appropriate for your situation.
You are able to file a request for premium processing my completing Form I-907, Request for Premium Processing Service. Discuss this with your attorney because you can file Form I-907 along with your I-140 or if you already filed the I-140 then you can file the premium processing request thereafter with the service center where your I-140 is pending.
There are several costs that might go into getting an EB3. The first one, which is mandatory, is the I-140 filing fee of $700. This fee is required every time the I-140 is filed (including for green card “porting”) and must be covered by your employer. The beneficiary is not permitted to pay this fee.
Once your I-140 is approved, you will either need to adjust your status or go through premium processing. Adjustment of status requires you to file an I-485 form with the USCIS along with a filing fee that you are responsible for and that varies based on your age. Here is the schedule:
- For those that are under the age of 14 and are filing alongside a parent, the fee is $750.
- For those that are under the age of 14 and are not filing alongside a parent, the fee is $1,140.
- For those that are between the ages of 14 and 78, the fee is $1,225 (includes $85 biometric service fee).
- For those that are over the age of 78, the fee is $1,140.
If you are going through consular processing, you will need to complete the DS-260 online immigrant visa application and pay the fee of $325 along with an affidavit of support fee of $120 for a total of $445. This must be done before arriving at the U.S. Consulate or Embassy for your EB-3 interview. You will also need to take any extra costs into account including travel fees, attorney fees, or the optional premium processing fee of $2,500.
Green cards differ from temporary work visas in that, aside from a few exceptions, they all offer the same exact benefits.
Pros
- Every green card provides the holder with lawful permanent residence, meaning that they can live and work in the U.S. almost without restrictions (except for federal jobs that require security clearance).
- Each green card is valid for ten years (With the exception of the EB5 and marriage-based green cards) after which time the holder will need to renew their green card.
- Renewal does not require the holder to re-qualify, only to pay the renewal fee and demonstrate that he or she has not committed any crimes or stayed outside of the U.S. for an extended period of time.
- As far as requirements go, the EB3 enjoys the lowest qualifications. You only need to have a non-seasonal job in order to qualify under the “other workers” category, so most workers are able to be eligible.
The only real differences between green cards are the qualifications and the final action dates.
Cons
- The EB3 often has the longest waiting period among employment-based green cards, so qualifying for an EB2 or EB1 will usually allow you to obtain your green card more quickly, especially if you are from a heavily-populated country such as China or India.
- EB3 requires a PERM Labor Certification in order to file the I-140. The PERM requires your employer to post your job in several places and to perform a recruitment process in order to ensure that you are not taking the job of a qualified U.S. worker. This is an extensive part of the process that is vulnerable to obstacles like PERM audits and supervised recruitment.
The EB1 does not require applicants to obtain a PERM and the EB2 allows you to avoid the PERM requirement if you obtain a National Interest Waiver. The EB3, on the other hand, does not provide an opportunity to avoid this step.
Getting the terms visa and green card confused is a common occurrence as many people think that they are different things. In reality, a green card is a visa.
A U.S. visa is an immigration vehicle that allows aliens to spend time in the United States.
There are two main types of visas—nonimmigrant visas and immigrant visas.
- Nonimmigrant visas are temporary and holders often return to their home countries at the end of the visa’s validation period. These include examples such as the H1B, L1, O1, and E2 visas.
- Immigrant visas are permanent. Holders are granted lawful permanent residence in the U.S., allowing them to live and work almost without restriction for an indefinite amount of time. Immigrant visas are commonly referred to as green cards due to the fact that permanent resident cards are greenish in color.
So, the EB3 visa and the EB3 green card are actually the same thing, since green cards are a type of visa.
As we covered in the last question, there are immigrant visas (green cards) and nonimmigrant visas. The EB3 is an immigrant visa, granting permanent residence to whoever holds it. The H1B is a nonimmigrant visa, allowing the holder to stay temporarily in the U.S. for work. H1B holders can typically only remain in the U.S. for a maximum of six years.
Additionally, there are differences in the requirements for the EB3 and H1B. To qualify for an EB3, you must either have a bachelor’s degree and a job offer or a non-seasonal full-time job offer. The H1B requires that you have both at least a bachelor’s degree and a job offer for a position that requires your degree.
Also, the H1B is so popular that the USCIS randomly selects the petitions that are to be processed from the large number of petitions that are submitted each year in a lottery. This means that your petition must be both randomly selected and subsequently approved in order to receive your H1B. The EB3 is not subject to this type of lottery.
However, there is an annual limit to the number of EB3 green cards that are issued. Rather than a randomized lottery though, the Department of State will give you a priority date. You will need to wait until that priority date matches the dates that are given in the monthly visa bulletin before moving forward.
Ultimately, the H1B is often the pathway that people use to get an EB3. You may choose to find a job and work temporarily as a nonimmigrant under the H1B before adjusting your status to immigrant status with an EB3.
Yes, you can. You would qualify under the bachelor’s degree qualification for the EB3. However, having an advanced degree (master’s or higher) is one of the qualifications for an EB2, so you may consider applying for one or both.
Yes. There are three types of people that qualify for the EB3.
- Those that have at least a bachelor’s degree
- Those that have at least 2 years of experience in their jobs
- Those that have less than 2 years of experience (but have non-seasonal jobs)
If you fall into either of the last two categories, you can obtain an EB3 without a degree.
Possibly. If you refer to the previous question, you’ll see that the third category is for those with less than 2 years of experience. However, this puts you into a slightly different area with different dates in the visa bulletin, so keep that in mind. You may also find it more difficult to get your I-140 approved with little to no experience than you would if you had at least some experience.
Yes. The H1B is a common way to get an EB3, but it is far from the only path. There are other nonimmigrant visas that are considered “dual intent” such as the O1, L1, and E visas. However, if you qualify for any of these, you might be better suited for an EB1 or EB2 green card, but that does not necessarily preclude you from the EB3.
Alternatively, you can obtain an EB3 without getting a nonimmigrant visa in the first place. By using consular processing and participating in a one-on-one interview with a consular officer at a U.S. Consulate or Embassy in your home country, you can enter the U.S. as a lawful permanent residence without adjusting your status.
Yes. There is nothing restricting you from filing for several different green cards simultaneously. You can also file for the same green card through different employers. This way, if one petition is denied, the other may still be open to you. If both are approved, you can simply choose.
Your priority date is specific to you and does not change. You can see your priority date on the notice of receipt from the USCIS, your I-797. 9. The priority date establishes a person’s place in line to get an immigrant visa. The Final Action Date chart in the Visa Bulletin indicates whether an immigrant visa number will be available.
The final action dates are based on the green card category and the chargeability area—your country of origin. Therefore, the final action dates constantly change based on how many people from each chargeability area have petitioned for that green card.
If green cards are still available, the final action date will likely move closer to your priority date. If green cards are unavailable, you will not see any movement from that final action date. However, if the limit has passed, you may see the date retrogress or move backward from your priority date. To check the final action dates in your category, you can visit the latest visa bulletin and compare it to your priority date.
There are several steps to the EB3 that can take varying amounts of time.
- Step 1 is the PERM Labor Certification. As we’ve mentioned, the PERM requires a recruitment process that takes a minimum of 60 days. The Department of Labor can take an average of six to nine months to process the form afterward. Also, if your employer is audited or subjected to supervised recruitment, it could add another nine months to a year and a half to the process.
- 2After that, your employer will file the I-140 with the USCIS, which takes an average of six months to process depending on how busy the service center is. This step can be expedited to just 15 calendar days with premium processing.
- Then, you will have to wait until your priority date is current. This has an enormous influence over your overall processing time, as the priority dates for some countries are already current while others may take many years.
- After that, you will need to go through either consular processing or adjustment of status. Adjusting your status requires filing the I-485 form, which takes about six months to process and is not eligible for premium processing. Consular processing can take a few weeks to a few months depending on how busy the U.S. Consulate or Embassy is in your home country.
Overall, the shortest waiting time could be about one year, while the longest waiting time could be over a decade. It all depends on your unique situation.
As we covered earlier, the priority date is the primary factor in determining your EB3 processing time. But here we can discuss the reason for priority dates. Each green card has an annual limit imposed by the Department of State. Rather than have a random lottery when a visa is oversubscribed, like the H1B, the DOS will process petitions in the order that they receive them. So the more people that petition for a particular green card, the longer it will take to process any single petition.
The final action dates are also divided according to country of origin. Countries that have a high number of annual petitioners are singled out while the others are grouped together in a general category. So if you are from a country that has a lot of EB3 petitioners, you will likely have to wait much longer than if you are from a country with fewer EB3 petitioners. For example, because there are so many EB3 petitioners from India, someone from that country would have to wait for everyone that petitioned before them before their priority date will be current.
If there are more petitions than available visas for a country in a given year, the final action date will retrogress (go backward). If the annual limit is met, then the final action date will see no movement. Finally, if there are fewer petitions than the limit, the final action date will move forward.
So, for this reason, if more people from your country apply for the EB2 than the EB3, the EB3 will be faster.
Technically, yes. With enough time, your EB3 date will eventually be current. However, because so many Indian citizens petition every year (often more than the annual limit), the movement of the final action date is consistently slowed, halted, or even retrogressed.
One question we often get here is if the EB3 can be transferred to an EB2. This is often from people whose priority dates will not be current for several years and are interested in obtaining their green card sooner. Going from an EB3 to an EB3 is called “porting” and is not as simple as it sounds.
In order to port, you will need to first obtain the qualifications for an EB2 (i.e. extraordinary ability in your field, an advanced degree, or having your work qualify for a national interest waiver). After that, you will need to find an employer who will both sponsor you and offer you a job that requires your new EB2 qualifications (e.g. a job that requires a master’s degree). It can either be your current employer offering you a new position or a new employer altogether. The important thing is that you find a new job.
Next, the employer who is sponsoring you for the EB2 will need to obtain another PERM Labor Certification (even if it is with the same employer). Your employer will also need to file a new I-140 petition for the EB2.
This may seem less like porting and more like starting over from scratch, and that’s not necessarily an inaccurate view. The only benefit to this is that you can request to have your priority date retained from your previous petition. This means that you will not have to start over in terms of waiting for your priority date to be current, you can pick up your EB2 right where your EB3 left off. If the date for the EB2 is current, you will be able to move forward as soon as your new petition is approved.
If your attempt to “port” is denied, your denial notice will inform you of whether or not you can appeal the decision or file the legal motions to reopen or reconsider your case. Reopening a case is used when you have new evidence to bring to your case and reconsidering is used when you can argue that the evaluating officer was incorrect in denying your application from a legal standpoint.
Fortunately, you will still have your EB3 petition to fall back on if your EB2 porting attempt was denied.
Yes. By using the same “porting” strategy as mentioned above, it is technically possible to petition for an EB1 and have your EB3 priority date retained. However, the EB1 is a very prestigious green card and there are very few who qualify. Speak with your immigration attorney to see if this is a path that is open to you.
How does USCIS determine a same or similar classification?
A number of factors are taken into account when USCIS decides if two jobs are similar enough to met the porting classification. These include:
- DOL SOC system
- Job responsibilities for each position
- Education, skill, licenses, certifications required to perform each job
- SOC code from Form I-140, Form 9089 (if applicable) and the SOC code of the new position
- Wages of each job
- Other evidence submitted
One of the main reasons that people work to obtain an EB3 is to make that final step to full-fledged U.S. citizenship. Citizens enjoy several benefits that green card holders do not, such as immunity from deportation, better preferences for sponsoring family members for green cards, and access to federal jobs that require security clearance.
The path from an EB3 to citizenship is the same for every green card. Aliens become citizens through a process called naturalization. You will first need to make sure that you fulfill the following requirements:
- You are at least 18 years old
- You meet any of these three criteria:
- You have been an EB3 holder for at least 5 years
- You have been married to a U.S. citizen for a minimum of 3 years
- You are serving in the United States military currently
Then, you will need to file an N-400 citizenship application form with the USCIS. You will also need to include a copy of your EB3 green card, passport-sized photos, and the N-400 processing fee of $725. Each case is different, however, so be sure to speak with your immigration attorney about what documentation and fees are required for you to go from EB-3 to citizenship status.
You will also need to show that you have good moral character (a metric that covers everything from committing crimes to marriage fidelity); that you can read and write in basic English; that you understand the core tenants of the U.S. constitution, history, and government; and that you have remained in the U.S. continuously for the amount of time required (i.e. 5 years or 3 years).
Possibly. Many people who file an I-485 to have their status adjusted to any green card are liable to be brought in for an interview. The EB3 is no exception. However, if you are prepared and your case is legitimate, you have nothing to fear from this interview. The evaluating officer will ask you questions from your I-485 and I-140 to ensure that you are the person that you say you are (questions like your employer, address, date of birth, etc.).
If your information has changed in a way that makes you ineligible (such as committing a crime or losing your sponsoring employer), then your application may be denied. However, do not let this cause you to lie to the officer. An application can always be refiled, but being caught in an attempt to immigrate fraudulently could result in a long-term or even permanent ban on re-entry into the U.S.